Live the Lake Life You Deserve – Lake Muskoday, NY

This is not your average lake listing — it’s a rare double-lot opportunity in the peaceful, private community of Lake Muskoday, just 2.5 hours from NYC.

Build your dream getaway (or future forever home) on a gently sloping lot — and enjoy your own lakefront lot directly across the street. Yes, your own waterfront for morning coffee, sunsets, or launching your kayak.

A previously engineered site plan and approved septic system are already in place — just needs updating. Translation? You’re ahead of the game.

Why Lake Muskoday?
This 54-acre gem is ideal for fishing, paddling, and non-motorized boating — so it stays peaceful and pristine. Plus, when you buy here, you have the option to join the Lake Association, which comes with:

A private sandy beach (yep, your own local beach)
Pavilion + picnic area for chill weekends or friend gatherings
Access to 200+ acres of private land for hiking, exploring, or just disconnecting

Bonus: Association shares are $1,500 (refundable when you leave) and dues are a very doable ~$300/year. © 2025 OneKey™ MLS, LLC