Nestled on 2.9 acres, this circa 1900 home was built by the same master craftsman responsible for Cragsmoor’s iconic Stone Church, a celebrated landmark known for its striking architecture and breathtaking panoramic mountain views, which are equally enjoyed from this property. In 2025, the home underwent a major renovation, adding a second floor while preserving the original first floor stone structure and historic details. The result is a perfect balance of timeless craftsmanship, raw beauty, and modern comforts.

Step inside and feel the seamless blend of past and present. Original stone walls and architectural details honor the home’s heritage, while the open-concept layout brings modern light and space. The farmhouse-style kitchen features an 8-foot granite island, high-end appliances, and a deep farmhouse sink. The inviting living room centers around a fireplace framed with original stonework, while glass doors lead to the fresh mountain air and stunning sunset views.

Upstairs, the newly built master suite offers a private balcony, walk-in closet (or nursery), and a spa-inspired bathroom. Two additional bedrooms, a full bath, and a laundry room complete the second floor. Comfort is ensured with central A/C, a high-efficiency HVAC system, and individual thermostats controlling supplemental electric baseboard heating. The oversized 2-car garage offers abundant storage and doubles easily as a workshop or creative studio.

Outdoors, the property is a private sanctuary surrounded by mature trees, native plants, and the peaceful charm Cragsmoor is known for. Nearby, explore Sam’s Point Preserve, Awosting Falls, and the scenic Shawangunk Ridge trails.
Close to the vibrant towns of Stone Ridge, Woodstock, New Paltz, and Kingston.

Under two hours from NYC, Cragsmoor offers not just natural beauty, but also a welcoming sense of community. 115 Schuyler Avenue is a rare find—offering historic soul, modern luxury, and a setting unlike anywhere else in the Hudson Valley. © 2025 OneKey™ MLS, LLC