The beautiful 73 Caroll Street is now a true SHOW-STOPPER! No longer occupied and
just-finished reconditioning! - If you saw it while occupied, I strongly encourage you to see it again!! All its stunning features can now be fully appreciated. Showings are no longer restricted, and it is back on the market!

This stunning Colonial home has been lovingly cared for and renovated throughout a century of one family's ownership. This 1620 sqft property with 4 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms is perfectly situated in a serene-like setting on an oversized lot of 5525 sqft. Caroll Street is a quiet and quaint street on City Island, with access to the water and a small private beach at the end of the street! – MAKE SURE YOU CHECK OUT THE ENCLOSED VIDEO. If you don’t see it, call, text or email me and I will send it to you. Alternatively search 73 Caroll Street City Island VIDEO on YouTube and it will show up.

On the first floor of this beautiful home, you will find a spacious living room with custom built-ins and a gas fireplace. You have a formal dining room, which could be used as a first-floor bedroom - already equipped with cedar closets, and with a full bathroom next to it. The additional enchanting alcove dining area - off the renovated kitchen; is one of my favorite rooms with its oversized windows. This entire home is bathed in light from its 22 windows of lovely green and open-sky views from every window! The second floor has an ideal layout of three spacious bedrooms, one smaller bedroom or office, and another full bathroom. The primary bedroom can be combined with the smaller bedroom, creating a fabulous primary bedroom suite with walk-in closets galore!

This oversized lot with its large backyard and lovely covered terrace is a true extension of the house for endless entertainment, al-fresco dining, lots of play, and perhaps a pool!

Life is easy at 73 Caroll Street, with a private driveway, carport and a covered pathway leading to the side entrance - making bringing in groceries a breeze! You have endless storage in the lower ceiling, but very dry raw basement, and this property has NEVER FLOODED, and does not need flood insurance.

This lovely property also comes with an additional 1160 buildable square feet of unused FAR. So if you want to build it out, you have the perfect property, lot, front, side and back yard to do so.

If you don’t know City Island it is time that you do! Its relaxed & friendly lifestyle makes it the best kept secret, with quick and easy access to Manhattan. No matter where you go you are always surrounded by water, multiple boat clubs, seafood restaurants and beaches! City Island also enjoys its own school (K-8), a library, post office, diner, café and delis, art galleries and quaint artifact stores. Live music is performed on weekends throughout the summer, and we now also have our very own Yoga and Pilates studio!
The adjacent Pelham Bay Park – is the largest park of NYC - 2,772 acres of walking, biking, and running trails, golf courses, a horse stable, and beaches. Life here is simply ideal.

Contact the listing broker directly for more information and to schedule a private showing.